Tufts University: Speech Code Controversy
FIRE commented on Tufts University's recent "Declaration on Freedom of Expression and Inquiry at Tufts University," pleased that Tufts University has decided to renew its commitment to freedom of expression. Unfortunately, the draft fails to adequately protect freedom of expression at Tufts and will, in all likelihood, invite more censorship and uncertainty while discouraging robust debate, candor, and dissent. The policy's most fundamental flaws are, first, that it fails to inspire students and faculty to value freedom of expression, and second, that its support for freedom of expression is far too equivocal...." FIRE concluded that "in crafting an inspiring document that touts Tufts' commitment to freedom of speech, it would seem wisest that the Task Force on Freedom of Expression not overemphasize the exceptions to freedom of expression. Unless the document helps students and faculty understand the sublime and sometimes painful power of speech to spark meaningful debate and discussion, it will likely fail in its overall mission, with the exceptions henceforth treated as more important than the general rule."
- "Comment from the Foundation for Individual Rights in Education on the “Declaration on Freedom of Expression and Inquiry at Tufts University”," October 6, 2008
- "Free Speech at Tufts University "Déja Vu" All Over Again," March 27, 2000: Twelve years after FIRE cofounder Harvey Silverglate helped slay the Tufts speech code, he returns to face the threat of a new code there.
Case Materials
- "Northeastern, Tufts fail free speech exam,"
by Benjamin Bell, Boston Herald, December 30, 2007 - "Administration Deals Blow to Campus Censorship,"
by Peter Brownfeld, FOXNews, August 29, 2003 - "David Limbaugh on Targeting Campus Speech Codes,"
by Michael Nevin, ChronWatch, August 17, 2003 - "Targeting campus speech codes,"
by David Limbaugh, Townhall, August 16, 2003