Repression and Double Standards at UMass Amherst

By October 15, 2004

AMHERST, Mass., October 14, 2004—Less than one year after the University of Massachusetts Amherst defended the free speech rights of a columnist who celebrated the death of Army Ranger Pat Tillman, the university has campaigned to persecute nine students who were seen in photographs containing a caricature of one of them as the “Grand Wizard” of the Ku Klux Klan. The drawing, which was intended to mock both the Klan itself and spurious accusations of “racism” made during the course of a student government election campaign, depicted the so-called Grand Wizard with his eyes crossed and his tongue hanging out of his mouth. The mere existence of such a drawing led UMass to charge the nine students with “harassment” and threaten them with penalties ranging from criminal charges to expulsion.

“Appalling double standards are, unfortunately, nothing new at America’s colleges and universities, but UMass has taken the unfair treatment of students to a new low,” said David French, president of the Foundation for Individual Rights in Education (FIRE), which is advocating on behalf of the students. “UMass officials know that the drawing was a constitutionally protected satire of accusations of racism made against a candidate in a student election, yet they have denounced the students in public as racists and are pushing ahead with plans to punish them.”

On March 26, 2004, after the elections for the UMass Student Government Association (SGA), several candidates gathered in a student organization office for a post-election party. One student at the party, Patrick Higgins, was defeated in a race for SGA President during which he was labeled a “racist” for opposing a plan to set aside a number of seats in the Student Senate solely for members of a campus group called ALANA. (Eventually the plan was judged unconstitutional by UMass’s own general counsel.) ALANA claims to represent “African, Latino/a, Asian/Pacific Islander, and Native American” students at UMass.

In an effort to mock the charges of racism, a person at the party drew a caricature of Higgins as a member of the Ku Klux Klan on a dry-erase board. The “Grand Wizard” was depicted wearing a pointed hat and a cape, and holding a burning cross. With his eyes crossed and his tongue hanging out of his mouth, the “Wizard” had a speech bubble written over his head that read, “I LOVE ALANA!!” One of the partygoers took photographs of the caricature and posted them on his personal website. An unknown student later circulated the photographs around campus, along with others that appear to show some of the partygoers drinking alcohol.

“Anyone looking at the caricature of the student as a ‘Grand Wizard’ can see that it is not an expression of support for the KKK,” commented Greg Lukianoff, FIRE’s director of legal and public advocacy. “In the context of the charges leveled during the election, it’s quite clear that the drawing is a satire of what the students felt was an unjust characterization of Higgins.”

After controversy erupted, UMass Amherst Vice Chancellor for Student Affairs Michael Gargano told the Daily Collegian campus newspaper, “I have the authority to remove these people from office…I could give them 500 hours of community service, have them conduct an open forum discussion; I have a variety of sanctions at my disposal. I’m not ruling out dismissal.” Gargano further articulated his threats at a September 27 “diversity panel,” stating, “[I]f the Student Government Association doesn’t move on it, I will. Are we clear? Resign!”

The same “diversity panel,” consisting of Gargano, SGA President Eduardo Bustamante, and several UMass faculty members, labeled the nine students in the photos the “KKK Nine,” implying that they supported the Ku Klux Klan. “Accusing students without any evidence of their affiliation with or sympathy for a racist terror organization is beyond slander. It shows a grave disregard for students, contempt for the principle of ‘innocent until proven guilty,’ and a lack of judgment bordering on malice,” said FIRE’s Lukianoff.

UMass has charged all nine students with “harassment conduct less than a physical attack” and other charges related to the consumption of alcohol. During the resulting judicial proceedings, UMass has offered “settlements” that include punishments far more severe than those typically imposed for first-time alcohol offenses.

On October 7, FIRE wrote UMass Amherst Chancellor John V. Lombardi on behalf of the students, pointing out that not only was the drawing irresponsibly mischaracterized, but that it was also constitutionally protected expression that UMass, as a state institution, was forbidden to punish. FIRE pointed out that “the First Amendment protects even extraordinarily offensive satire and parody,” and emphasized that any punishment decisions “must be made without reference to the ‘offensive’ caricature.” Read FIRE’s letter to UMass.

UMass’s actions in this case stand in stark contrast to its treatment of Rene Gonzalez, a UMass graduate student who wrote an article for the Daily Collegian last spring that called NFL player turned Army Ranger Pat Tillman an “idiot” and said that “this was a ‘G.I. Joe’ guy who got what was coming to him.” UMass rightly refused to take official action against Gonzalez. Instead, UMass system President Jack Wilson responded, “While I recognize Rene Gonzalez’s right of free speech, I must also assert my right of free speech to criticize what he said.”

“President Wilson made the right decision once, and we are hopeful that he will do so again in the face of the hysteria surrounding this drawing. We hope that President Wilson and Chancellor Lombardi will demonstrate continued faith in the power of the marketplace of ideas to deal with expression that some might find offensive. Otherwise, UMass will become just one other disappointing example of the many colleges and universities that simply give up on free speech,” concluded FIRE’s French.

FIRE is a nonprofit educational foundation that unites civil rights and civil liberties leaders, scholars, journalists, and public intellectuals from across the political and ideological spectrum on behalf of individual rights, due process, freedom of expression, academic freedom, and rights of conscience at our nation’s colleges and universities. FIRE’s efforts to preserve liberty at UMass Amherst and on campuses across America can be viewed at www.thefire.org.

CONTACT:

Greg Lukianoff, Director of Legal and Public Advocacy, FIRE: 215-717-3473; greg@thefire.org

John V. Lombardi, Chancellor, UMass Amherst: 413-545-2211; lombardi@umass.edu

Michael Gargano, Vice Chancellor of Student Affairs, UMass Amherst: 413-545-2333; dunk@stuaf.umass.edu

Schools: University of Massachusetts – Amherst