AMHERST, Mass., April 23, 2009—Under pressure from the Foundation for Individual Rights in Education (FIRE), University of Massachusetts Amherst has rejected the student government’s official censorship of The Minuteman, a conservative campus newspaper that mocked a student government official. In addition, FIRE has learned that UMass Amherst has held accountable at least one of the people who stole copies of The Minuteman out of the hands of a student while a campus police officer watched and did nothing.
“Supreme Court Justice Louis Brandeis was right: Sunlight is the best of disinfectants,” FIRE President Greg Lukianoff said. “Next time, maybe UMass and its police won’t wait for outside pressure before taking action to uphold the First Amendment on campus.”
Mob censorship through the theft of newspapers is a recurring problem on America’s campuses. Several video recordings of the newspaper theft at UMass show a UMass police officer idly standing by as hundreds of copies of The Minuteman are stolen out of the hands of a student intending to distribute the paper.
One of the individuals who stole the papers, shown in a photograph as standing on a stack of papers and on video as grabbing them out of the other student’s hands, has been identified to FIRE as student Vanessa Snow. Snow is the leader of UMass’ Student Bridges, a campus organization supported by the UMass Amherst Student Government Association (SGA). Snow was ridiculed by name in that issue of The Minuteman. She reportedly was reprimanded for the theft.
As if the theft was not enough, The Minuteman‘s mockery of Snow also resulted in official censorship. The SGA passed a resolution demanding that The Silent Majority, the student organization that publishes The Minuteman, publicly apologize to Vanessa Snow for its constitutionally protected mockery of her or face loss of recognition, which would shut down both the organization and the paper. At the request of The Silent Majority, FIRE wrote to UMass Amherst Chancellor Robert C. Holub urging that the coerced speech and threat of punishment be rescinded immediately.
While FIRE awaited an answer from the administration, one student senator, Derek Khanna, tried to restore the First Amendment to campus by placing a resolution on the SGA agenda that would have rescinded the censorship resolution without the administration’s help. SGA Senate Speaker Shaun Robinson not only refused to hear Khanna’s resolution but reportedly threw it on the floor, calling the police to eject Khanna from the SGA meeting after Khanna insisted that he be heard.
Of course, Khanna was eventually proved absolutely right when the UMass administration finally invoked its veto power and rejected the resolution. “As the enactment does not reflect an appreciation of the Silent Majority’s constitutional right to the exercise of free speech,” Vice Chancellor for Student Affairs and Campus Life Esther Terry wrote, “I reject it altogether and recommend that it be rescinded in its entirety.”
UMass Amherst has been plagued with free speech problems since February, when a large group of students invited people to protest at a speech by columnist Don Feder that was to be hosted by the Republican Club. In response, the UMass Police Department pressured the Republican Club into paying an additional $444.52 for extra security at the event due to the threatened protest. The club agreed to pay the money, but the organized hecklers nevertheless disrupted Feder’s speech. (Video of the disrupted event is available online.) Under pressure from FIRE, including an op-ed in The Boston Globe, UMass publicly relented in a letter to the Globe. The letter announced that UMass would return the excess fee, but it deceptively claimed that UMass had only charged more money because of greater anticipated attendance at Feder’s lecture.
Protesters also disrupted a speech by Mike S. Adams at UMass Amherst in 2006. “We’ll see if UMass has learned anything about free speech on April 30, when Mike S. Adams returns to campus,” said Adam Kissel, Director of FIRE’s Individual Rights Defense Program.
FIRE is a nonprofit educational foundation that unites civil rights and civil liberties leaders, scholars, journalists, and public intellectuals from across the political and ideological spectrum on behalf of individual rights, due process, freedom of expression, academic freedom, and rights of conscience at our nation’s colleges and universities. FIRE’s efforts to preserve liberty at UMass Amherst and on campuses across America are detailed at thefire.org.
Adam Kissel, Director, FIRE’s Individual Rights Defense Program: 215-717-3473; firstname.lastname@example.org
Robert C. Holub, Chancellor, UMass Amherst: 413-545-2211; email@example.com
Shaun Robinson, Speaker of the Senate, UMass Amherst SGA: 412-545-0342; firstname.lastname@example.org
Schools: Boston College University of Massachusetts – Amherst Cases: University of Massachusetts at Amherst: Student Newspapers Stolen While Police Officer Watches University of Massachusetts at Amherst: Student Government Tries to Punish Conservative Newspaper University of Massachusetts Amherst: Student Group Charged Unconstitutional Security Fee for Controversial Speaker