Table of Contents
What’s The Problem With Social Justice?
When FIRE criticizes institutions for assessing students based on their commitments to concepts such as “social justice,” one common question we hear is: what’s so wrong with that? Can’t everyone agree that social justice is a good thing?
The problem is that in academia, certain terms, including social justice, have become politically and ideologically loaded. Mark Bauerlein, a professor of English at Emory University, provides interesting insight into this phenomenon today on Inside Higher Ed. Bauerlein discusses how academics first propagated the notion that that language has “implicit meaning…much of it political or identity-oriented,” and yet are now falling back on the traditionally “conservative” notion that words should be taken at face value in order to defend themselves against charges of bias (such as the charge that it is inappropriate to judge people on their commitment to social justice.)
Bauerlein also notes that academics tend to issue denials when charged with bias in their use of politically-charged language. Of these people, Bauerlein asks: “Have they lived so long and so closely to ‘social justice,’ ‘social change,’…and ‘gender equality’ that they do not recognize them as loaded terms? ... By their own instruction, we should regard the widespread attention to race, gender, and social construction as emanating from a world view and signaling an ideological commitment.”
Those who do not see the danger inherent in judging people on the basis of their commitment to terms like “social justice” would do well to read Bauerlein’s thought-provoking article.
Recent Articles
FIRE’s award-winning Newsdesk covers the free speech news you need to stay informed.
LAWSUIT: Historian fights back after Pennsylvania state senator sues him for criticizing book
Sen. Doug Mastriano’s lawsuit is a textbook “SLAPP” case, in which powerful individuals sue their critics into silence through long, costly litigation.
FIRE statement on California’s Defending Democracy from Deepfake Deception Act
AB 2655 threatens Californians’ right to speak freely about politics in their state.
House passes historic legislation protecting free speech on college campuses
Public colleges must do more to protect the First Amendment rights of students and faculty on campus, according to a new bill in the House.
Kamala Harris comedy roast denied funding by University of South Carolina student senate
Despite pushback, the student senate denied funding to the student group Uncensored America for the event in a blatant example of viewpoint discrimination.