Binghamton University: Social Work Student Expelled

Category: Free Speech
Schools: Binghamton University, State University of New York

Binghamton University graduate student Michael Gutsell was expelled by the Department of Social Work following two incidents where his classroom speech drew complaints from fellow students. Despite the fact that the speech was relevant to the class and broke no university or department rules, the hearing panel recommended his dismissal. After appealing the decision, however, Gutsell learned that these two incidents were “not the primary basis” for his expulsion, and that BU may have determined that he was unfit for social work because he was not conforming to others’ subjective expectations about individuals’ proper conversational style, even outside of the professional context. The appeals panel upheld his expulsion without explaining to Gutsell what other factors it may have considered or giving him an opportunity to defend himself against them. Notably, the department had forced Gutsell to sign a contract earlier in the semester, one of the conditions of which was that the department could never hear that he had made any fellow students or instructors “uncomfortable.” Gutsell has had to leave the United States and return to his native Canada as a result of his expulsion. Binghamton did not respond to FIRE’s letter detailing our concerns and asking the university to respect Gutsell’s rights.

  • ‘Best of’ edition includes list of ‘worst’ colleges

    September 1, 2010

    Civil-rights organization highlights universities that are ‘unrepentant’ violators by Bob Unruh WorldNetDaily   A permanent blemish on a student’s record for a parody, an attempted expulsion for criticism of a “social injustice” and the formal censorship of a political satire: All of these actions have earned American colleges and universities a citation in a full-page ad in U.S. News & World Report’s 2011 edition of its “Best Colleges” issue. The ad warns parents and students to “think twice” about considering attending the schools. The ad was taken out by the Foundation for Individual Rights in Education, which highlighted Bucknell University, […]

    » Read More

  • Why Binghamton University is One of Our ’12 Worst Colleges for Free Speech’

    February 1, 2011

    By now, I hope you’ve had a chance to read our list of the “12 Worst Colleges for Free Speech,” which we highlighted on The Huffington Post last week. Our “Dirty Dozen”—which is made up of the six colleges and universities on our Red Alert list, as well as six other institutions that have shown a profound disregard for free speech rights over the years—has quickly generated a good deal of attention and response. Peter explained on Friday why DePaul University was one of the schools outside of our Red Alert list to be selected for this dubious distinction. Today, […]

    » Read More

  • Binghamton’s Social Work Department Strikes Again, Expelling Student Without Feeling the Need to Tell Him Why

    February 9, 2010

    A year after The Torch was so populated with eye-popping accounts of Binghamton University’s (BU’s) attempts to force graduate student Andre Massena out of its Masters of Social Work (MSW) program, the student newspaper the Binghamton Review lays bare the case of another MSW student, Michael Gutsell, caught in the crosswinds of the Department of Social Work’s vague and unforgiving disciplinary system. Unfortunately, despite FIRE’s appeals to the BU administration to apply basic fairness and respect for students’ First Amendment rights to his case, Gutsell was expelled from the MSW program without knowing why, much less having a chance to […]

    » Read More

  • FIRE Laura Bronstein

    February 1, 2010

    FIRE Laura Bronstein                                              

    » Read More

  • FIRE and the State of Speech on Campuses

    February 1, 2010

    FIRE and the State of Speech on Campuses                                              

    » Read More

  • The Systematic Attack on Free Expression in Binghamton University’s Masters of Social Work Program

    January 1, 2010

    Michael Gutsell Review Article                                              

    » Read More

  • FIRE Letter to Binghamton University President Lois B. DeFleur

    December 11, 2009

    December 11, 2009 Lois B. DeFleur President, Binghamton University Office of the President P.O. Box 6000 Binghamton, New York 13902-6000 URGENT Sent via U.S. Mail and Facsimile (607-777-2533) Dear President DeFleur: The Foundation for Individual Rights in Education (FIRE) is disappointed to be writing you once again about violations of the rights of a student in the Department of Social Work at Binghamton University (BU). FIRE last wrote you on October 29, 2008, after the department punished Master in Social Work (MSW) student Andre Massena for his protected speech. Today, FIRE is concerned about the threats to freedom of expression, […]

    » Read More