Portland State University: Student Disciplined for Phone Call to Library Employee

March 18, 2011

On March 16, 2011, Portland State University student Rachel Cain had a telephone conversation with a PSU library employee concerning a library policy. Cain was not satisfied and left a phone message for the employee, criticizing the employee’s professionalism. Cain was later notified that her phone call had been reported to PSU’s student life office, and on March 23, Cain was charged with “Obstruction or Disruption of University Activity or Process” and “Failure to comply with a University Official’s requests.” She was found responsible for both charges, charged a $10 discipline fee, and asked to sign a “Behavioral Agreement.” Cain […]

» Read More

Acceptable Use Policy 05-06

Speech Code Category: Other Speech Codes, Statement
Last updated: June 13, 2003

Conduct which violates this policy includes, but is not limited to the following:

[...]

- Sending, storing, or accessing fraudulent, harassing, or obscene messages and/or materials on PSU systems.

» Read More

Student Rights and Responsibilities

Speech Code Category: Advertised Commitments to Free Expression, Statement
Last updated: June 11, 2003

» Read More

Policy Statement on Rights, Freedoms and Responsibilities of Students 05-06

Speech Code Category: Advertised Commitments to Free Expression, Statement
Last updated: June 11, 2003

» Read More

Proscribed Conduct 05-06

Speech Code Category: Harassment Policies, Statement
Last updated: December 15, 2013

» Read More

Proscribed Conduct – Sexual Harassment 05-06

Speech Code Category: Harassment Policies, Statement
Last updated: December 15, 2013

(10) Sexual harassment, defined as unwanted and unwelcome sexual advances or requests for sexual favors and other verbal or physical conduct of a sexual nature where:

[...]

(c) such conduct has the purpose or effect of unreasonably interfering with an individual's academic or work performance, or of creating an intimidating, hostile or offensive educational or working environment.

» Read More

Eligibility for Student Fees Funding 05-06

Speech Code Category: Other Speech Codes, Statement
Last updated: June 11, 2003

1. Eligibility for funding from Student Fees requires the activity, program, or service to satisfy the requirements in one of the following three categories (OAR 580-010-0090):

[...]

b) Educational, Cultural, and Student Government Activities. Programs or activities in this category must fulfill the requirements of one of the following four groups:

[...]

iii) Student publications. All such publications must have the written endorsement of the Publications Board of Portland State University, which serves as publisher of all student publications. The Publications Board shall evaluate and make recommendations concerning publications and their budget requests;

[...]

» Read More

Oregon College Conservatives Slam Portland State University For Declining ‘Murder-Free Zone’ Proposal, Calling It ‘Libelous’

July 15, 2015

By Hanna Sanchez at iSchoolGuide Officials at Portland State University in Oregon have turned down a college conservative group’s proposal to set up a table on campus to promote the idea of a “murder-free zone.” The idea is an extension of the “gun free zones” on campus, as well as in buildings in Portland. School officials feared that the group’s efforts could promote violence against them. Christian Bripschgi, the political director of Portland State’s College Republican Federation chapter, said university officials said the propopsal could be “triggering,” and “libelous.” The group, as well as First Amendment advocates, said school officials […]

» Read More

College Conservatives Denied Petition For “Murder-Free Zone” Because It’s “Triggering”

July 14, 2015

By Laura Meyers at The Libertarian Republic In an effort to mock gun-free zones and the idea of banning unwanted behavior by decree, a College Republican chapter at Portland State University asked permission from their administration to table and garner student support for a “murder free zone” on campus. “In the murder-free zone we were looking to create, nobody will be killed with guns, knives, sticks, or anything of the sort,” said Christian Bripschgi, political director of Oregon’s College Republican Federation chapter. Administrators denied the group’s request and said the proposal could be “libelous,” “triggering” and cause people to attack the students. Can […]

» Read More

College Conservatives’ ‘Murder-Free Zone’ A No-Go On Oregon Campus

July 13, 2015

By Alexandra Hennessey at Fox News It was supposed to be a stunt to point out the silliness of banning unwanted activity by decree, but a college conservative group in Oregon was stunned at the reason school officials killed their proposed “murder free zone.” Portland State University’s College Republicans chapter sought permission to set up a table on campus to generate support for the idea, but school officials said their effort could promote violence against them. Now the group and First Amendment advocates say it is school officials who need to study up – on the Constitution. “In the murder-free […]

» Read More

Henry Liu: Arrested, Locked in a Mental Ward, Discredited – On the Word of One Accuser

August 2, 2012

By Lisa Loving at The Skanner News UPDATE: As of February, 2013, Henry Liu has not been charged with any crime or misdemeanor connected to the PSU “timely warning” complaint. However Liu incurred significant legal bills in his unsuccessful effort to fight his expulsion from Portland State; he is also on the hook for medical bills incurred from his voluntary stay in the OHSU psych ward. He has set up a legal defense fund with links to a PDF of his mental health evaluation — which returned a clean bill of mental health — on this website. What if someone […]

» Read More

Oregon Student Expelled Over Threat Seeks Return

July 26, 2012

Steven DuBois at The Associated Press A Portland State University graduate student expelled after allegedly threatening violence against a faculty member wants to return to the university. … Read more here.  

» Read More

Was Portland State right in expelling student as safety risk? The student says no; the university says yes

July 25, 2012

By Bryan Denson at The Oregonian Henry Liu was a promising graduate student in Portland State University’s conflict resolution program. He had excellent grades, with law school on the horizon. But his academic career swiftly derailed last spring after he confided to a classmate that he was upset with a faculty member and mentioned guns in the same conversation. … Read more here.

» Read More

OSPIRG: down but not out

April 8, 2005

In the middle of an unusually warm February earlier this year, the talk all over campus was OSPIRG. For the past three years, the activist group has wrangled with student government over how much money would be allocated to their efforts at PSU. This year, after two hours of deliberation OSPIRG got its answer. No large increase, no large payout. Student government again was not swayed by the group’s impassioned pleas for funding and sent them packing with thousands less than they had asked for. Students came pouring out of the meeting crying, aghast that their efforts had failed for […]

» Read More

More Campus Leaders Address Free Speech Following Election

November 21, 2016

For the past few months, we’ve been covering the statements campus leaders make about free speech at their colleges or universities. In the weeks following this month’s presidential election, campus leaders have addressed their students’ reactions to the results in various ways—some “good,” and others “bad” for freedom of expression. The Good Central Washington University (CWU) CWU President James Gaudino made a post-election statement November 9 encouraging his students to continue to “debate and disagree”: President Obama today encouraged us all to move forward with faith in our fellow citizens and urged us all to hold on to our dreams. […]

» Read More

Oregon Appeals Court Rules for Student Expelled for Purported Threat

October 4, 2016

Four years ago, FIRE reported on the case of Henry Liu, a former graduate student who was expelled from Portland State University (PSU) for purportedly threatening to shoot two faculty members. On September 28, the Court of Appeals of the State of Oregon ruled that in the adjudicative hearing that resulted in Liu’s expulsion, PSU failed to follow required procedures under then-existing provisions of Oregon’s Administrative Procedures Act (APA). In its ruling, the court summarized the facts of the case: On April 20, 2012, a PSU professor reported that a student had told her that petitioner, a PSU graduate student, […]

» Read More

Portland State University Admins Demonstrate Support for Controversial Student Speech

June 13, 2013

The Portland State Vanguard reported last week on a controversy at Portland State University (PSU) between PSU’s College Republicans and the school’s Muslim Students Association (MSA). The MSA and other students criticized two events sponsored by the College Republicans in May—a visiting speaker’s lecture and a movie screening—as being anti-Islam, and they asked the PSU administration to address their concerns. However, the university administrators, to their credit, took the opportunity to remind students that the First Amendment protects speech even when it is offensive or hurtful to some.  The Vanguard gets to the heart of the matter:  " We met […]

» Read More

Associated Press and ‘Oregonian’: Portland State Student Expelled for Alleged “Threat”

July 27, 2012

This week, FIRE was quoted in two newspaper articles covering the story of a Portland State University graduate student, Henry Liu, who was expelled from the university last month for allegedly constituting a campus threat. As The Oregonian reports, Liu was expelled for allegedly expressing frustration about a faculty member to a classmate and mentioning firearms in the same conversation: Liu’s classmate told police he vented loudly about the conflict resolution program and its chairman, Robert Gould, saying, “I’m about ready to stick a .45 in his ass.” She said that Liu had complained about his chronic back problem and sleeplessness, and that he […]

» Read More

Victory: Portland State University Rescinds Charges Against Student over Phone Call with Employee

October 17, 2011

I’m pleased to announce that Portland State University (PSU) student Rachel Cain’s record has been wiped clean after she was initially found guilty of charges of “disruption” and “failure to comply” due to the content of a telephone conversation between Cain and an employee of PSU’s library system. Her case—like others we’ve seen at FIRE—is a useful reminder of why universities cannot hold students to the same speech standards to which they may hold their employees, a worrying trend on college campuses today. Here are the facts of Cain’s case. On March 16, 2011, Cain had a telephone conversation with […]

» Read More