Marquette University
Location: Milwaukee, Wisconsin
Website: http://www.marquette.edu
Type: Private
Federal Circuit: 7th Circuit
Speech Code Rating
Marquette University has been given the speech code rating Red. A red light university has at least one policy that both clearly and substantially restricts freedom of speech. Read more here.
-
Marquette University: Faculty Member Facing Loss of Tenure for Opinions on Blog
February 5, 2015
A professor’s job is at risk after he wrote a blog criticizing another instructor.
» Read More -
Marquette University: Political Quote Banned from Office Door
September 27, 2006
In August 2006, a PhD student at Marquette University, Stuart Ditsler, posted a Dave Barry quote on his office door. The quote read, “As Americans we must always remember that we all have a common enemy, an enemy that is dangerous, powerful, and relentless. I refer, of course, to the federal government.” In September, the University administration had the quote taken down because it was “patently offensive.” On September 5, Distler received an email from the Philosophy Department Chair, James South, stating that there had been several complaints about the quote and that it had been removed as a result. […]
» Read More
Red Light Policies
Student Organization Policies
Speech Code Category: Posting and Distribution Policies
Last updated: October 17, 2017Student organization requests for the distribution of literature and publicity, the sponsorship of visiting speakers and public performers and the screening of films will be considered in light of the educational purposes and the Catholic identity of Marquette University. Specific attention, therefore, will be paid to the context and purpose of the proposed material.
The University has final discretion in all decisions regarding the distribution of literature and publicity, the sponsorship of visiting speakers and public performances, and the screening of films. In keeping with the intellectual imperative of the University and the instructive value of dialogue, educational or artistic merit and a balanced perspective will be the normative basis for decisions by the Office of Student Development.
…
The university provides for the distribution of literature by student organizations. The following guidelines apply:
• Only members of the registered student organizations may distribute literature.
• Only approved literature deemed appropriate by the Office of Student Development may be distributed.
• The literature shall clearly identify the student organization responsible for the literature…
Material to be posted must be submitted to the Office of Student Development no later two weeks prior to the proposed date of posting, and Marquette Involvement Link event submissions must include the publicity.
…
All advertising and publicity that contravenes the moral teachings of the Catholic faith or is contrary to Marquette’s Jesuit mission and philosophy will not be approved.
…
The content of the postings must avoid demeaning or discriminatory portrayals of individual groups, cannot be libelous, violate copyright law, or contain any material that is inconsistent with the community standards of Marquette, including any reference to alcohol, drugs, or sexual innuendos.
a. The Office of Student Development will not approve literature that includes language or graphic illustrations that dehumanize individuals or foster intolerance of others because of their race, age, nationality, religion, gender, sexual orientation, disability or any other characteristic protected by applicable laws.
b. Materials will not be approved if they contain offensive language or images.
Marquette University Title IX Sexual Harassment, Discrimination and Sexual Misconduct Policy
Speech Code Category: Harassment Policies
Last updated: October 17, 2017- SEXUAL HARASSMENT
- Unwelcome conduct that is of an implicitly or overtly sexual nature, or is based on a person’s actual or perceived sex, gender, sexual orientation, gender identity, or gender expression.
- Gender-based verbal or physical conduct that is sufficiently severe, persistent or pervasive that it has the effect of unreasonably interfering with, denying, or limiting someone’s ability to participate in or benefit from the University’s education programs, employment and/or activities.
…
- Examples of prohibited harassment take a variety of forms and may include, but are not limited to, the following:
- Sexual advances, propositions, requests or pressure of any kind for sexual favors under any of the circumstances described above
- Sexually explicit, graphic, abusive, degrading, intimidating, or offensive jokes, comments, remarks, or gestures, under any of the circumstances described above
- Physical contact or intimidation under any of the circumstances described above
- Display, circulation, or communication of any sexually suggestive, explicit, graphic, or offensive objects, pictures, or materials of any kind, under any of the circumstances described above
- Epithets, slurs, negative stereotyping, or threatening, intimidating, or hostile acts that relate to an individual’s race, color, national origin, religion, age, disability, sex, gender identity/expression, sexual orientation, marital status, pregnancy, predisposing genetic characteristic, or military status, or any other characteristics protected by this policy and/or law, under any of the circumstances described above.
- Placing on walls, bulletin boards, email, social networking websites, or elsewhere on the University’s premises graphic material that shows hostility or aversion to an individual or group (as listed above) because of an individual’s race, color, national origin, religion, age, disability, sex, gender identity/expression, sexual orientation, marital status, pregnancy, predisposing genetic characteristic, or military status or any other characteristics protected by this Policy and/or law, under any of the circumstances described in this section.
- SEXUAL HARASSMENT
Student Conduct Code: Community Expectations
Speech Code Category: Harassment Policies
Last updated: October 17, 2017Marquette expects its members to behave toward one another with sensitivity, consideration, understanding, tolerance and an active concern for the welfare of others. The university is particularly concerned that its members show respect for others regardless of race, creed, gender, disability, sexual orientation or nationality and avoid all forms of harassing or offensive behaviors.
…
The following acts may subject students to disciplinary action: … Participating in stalking, hazing or harassment, which includes actions or situations that do or could result in mental, emotional or physical discomfort, embarrassment, ridicule or endangerment whether intentionally, for fun or by consent. …
Residence Life Policies and Procedures: Solicitation
Speech Code Category: Posting and Distribution Policies
Last updated: October 17, 2017Solicitation is defined as any activity that seeks to entice or gain support from resident students at Marquette. Therefore, this policy applies to a wide range of activities, all of which are prohibited unless specifically approved by Residence Life. These activities may include advertising, selling, petitioning, campaigning for political candidates, distributing flyers in mail boxes and surveying residence hall students by telephone, mail or in person.
Posters and signs in student rooms and windows are permissible provided they are in good taste. Residents may post signs, notices or posters on their doors as long as they do not damage the doors. Students may be asked remove items from their doors if the item may be considered offensive to their community. Students are not allowed to post unapproved items in common areas. See the hall director for approval.
Acceptable Use Policy
Speech Code Category: Internet Usage Policies
Last updated: October 17, 2017Users may not do the following: … Engage in activities that harass, degrade, intimidate, demean, slander, defame, interfere with, or threaten others.
Demonstrations Policy
Speech Code Category: Protest and Demonstration Policies
Last updated: October 17, 2017A member of the Marquette University community (student, faculty or staff member) must be designated Organizer/Liaison for each protest/demonstration (the “Event”).
The Organizer/Liaison must meet with the Dean of Students or designee to coordinate the planned Event and is encouraged to schedule this meeting well in advance. To schedule this meeting, the organizer must contact the Dean of Students office. If the Organizer/Liaison is planning the Event on behalf of a recognized club or organization, the advisor to the club or organization should is strongly encouraged to attend this meeting as well.
The Dean of Students/designate will meet with the organizer (and advisor, if relevant) within one business day of the request. The planned Event may be scheduled no fewer than two business days after this meeting is held. This two-day period may be extended at the discretion of the University if additional planning or preparation time is needed. Organizers should therefore plan accordingly and submit proposals as early as possible before the anticipated Event date. The meeting with the Dean/designate will be to review the details of the proposed Event including proposed time, place, manner and planned size of the event. Accordingly, expectations, rights, responsibilities, and logistical considerations will be discussed. In conjunction with this meeting, the Organizer/Liaison with submit a “Demonstration Proposal” form. This form is available through Marquette Involvement Link (URL). Following this meeting, if all parties are in agreement regarding the substance of the proposed Event and the institutional expectations, the Event will be approved and the Proposal Form will be shared with relevant campus offices.
Division of Student Affairs: Bias Incidents
Speech Code Category: Policies on Bias and Hate Speech
Last updated: October 17, 2017A bias incident is any discriminatory or hurtful act that appears to be motivated or is perceived by the victim or victims to be motivated by race, ethnicity, religion, age, national origin, sex, disability, gender identity or expression, sexual orientation, veteran or socioeconomic status. To be considered a bias incident, the act is not required to be a crime under any federal, state or local statutes. Colleges and universities may handle bias incidents through grievance procedures, such as the student conduct process, or through educational programs to enhance awareness and enable prevention of such acts.
Student Conduct Code: Community Expectations
Speech Code Category: Policies on Tolerance, Respect, and Civility
Last updated: October 17, 2017The following acts may subject students to disciplinary action: … Physically or verbally abusing or threatening any person, on or off the campus, including especially such persons as student staff and Public Safety officers. … Engaging in behaviors that are disruptive to the educational community, in or out of the classroom.
Religious Activities Policy
Speech Code Category: Other Speech Codes
Last updated: June 6, 2018[T]he university does not allow any other individual or organization internal or external to the university to proselytize its members using facilities, programs or activities controlled by the university. Proselytization is understood as any effort to influence people’s faith convictions, choices, or commitments in ways that de-personalize or deprive them of their inherent value as persons. … Additional activities that might be indicators of proselytizing include, but are not limited to:
…Making unjust or uncharitable references to others’ beliefs and practices;
Harassment Policy
Speech Code Category: Harassment Policies
Last updated: October 17, 2017Harassment, as defined by this Policy, includes any action, language or visual representation, based on any characteristic protected by law including race, color, gender, age, sexual orientation, religion, disability, veteran’s status or national origin, that is sufficiently severe, pervasive, persistent or patently offensive that it has the effect of unreasonably interfering with that individual’s work or academic performance, or that creates a hostile working, educational or living environment.
…
Non-discriminatory harassment as defined by this Policy, includes any action, language or visual representation, that is sufficiently severe, pervasive, persistent or patently offensive that it has the effect of unreasonably interfering with that person’s work or academic performance, or that creates an intimidating, hostile, or offensive working, educational, or living environment.
-
Divided Wisconsin Supreme Court Backs Marquette Faculty Blogger
July 9, 2018
by Colleen Flaherty at Inside Higher Ed Marquette University must immediately reinstate and pay damages to John McAdams, the political science professor who criticized a graduate student by name on his personal blog over how she handled a classroom discussion that turned to gay marriage… Read more here.
» Read More -
McAdams: Conservative students like ‘insurgents’ on campus
February 27, 2017
By Anthony Gockowski at Campus Reform Dr. John McAdams, the Marquette University professor suspended for a blog post, encouraged conservative students to be “more willing to speak out” at the 2017 Conservative Political Action Conference (CPAC)… Read more here.
» Read More -
‘Martyr to political correctness’ John McAdams to receive Academic Freedom award
February 23, 2017
By M.D. Kittle at Wisconsin Watchdog Still fighting for his speech and contractual rights two years after Marquette University drove him out of the classroom, Professor John McAdams will receive a top national academic freedom prize Friday at the Conservative Political Action Conference in National Harbor, Maryland… Read more here.
» Read More -
Marquette University and “Hard to Hear” Opinions
February 6, 2017
by Jerry Bader at WSAU. The Winter Edition of Marquette University’s “Marquette Magazine” includes what appears to be a self-congratulatory piece where open expression on campus is concerned, through its yearlong Marquette Forum series. The column chronicles the university’s fall semester efforts to generate discourse on the topic of racial justice and inequality… Read more here.
» Read More -
Judge to decide if summary judgment is to be made in McAdams case
February 3, 2017
By James Wigderson at Watchdog MILWAUKEE — After being banished from the classroom more than two years ago by Marquette University, professor John McAdams appeared in a Milwaukee County courtroom Thursday to ask Judge David Hansher to let him teach again. Read more here.
» Read More -
Marquette Official Who Schemed To Keep Out Ben Shapiro Event Attendees Being ‘Reprimanded’
February 2, 2017
By James Wigderson at Wisconsin Watchdog To stop Marquette University students from seeing conservative pundit Ben Shapiro, an official with Marquette University’s Center for Gender and Sexualities Studies tried to encourage people to grab up the free tickets and then not show up… Read more here.
» Read More -
Scariest People of 2016: No. 8-Michael Lovell
December 27, 2016
By John Bicknell at Townhall 2016 might go down as one of the most unusual years in the history of American politics. Voters chose historic change, but in all too many ways, it was business as usual… Read more here.
» Read More -
Conservative Tenured Professor sues Marquette for Promising to Fire him for Blogging
May 2, 2016
By Staff at The College Fix Marquette University Prof. John McAdams has made good on his threat last month to sue the Jesuit institution for infringing on his academic freedom… Read more here.
» Read More -
John McAdams Marches On
April 18, 2016
By RT Both at Urban Milwaukee Abbate, of course, was just using a tactic typical among liberals now. Opinions with which they disagree are not merely wrong, and are not to be argued against on their merits, but are deemed “offensive” and need to be shut up. –Marquette Warrior blog post, November 9, 2014 Is this protected speech under the First Amendment to the United States constitution? Undoubtedly. But are these the words of a professional in the academic discipline of political science?… Read more here.
» Read More -
At Marquette, it’s ‘Speak at Your own Risk’
April 15, 2016
By James Wigderson at Wisconsin Watchdog In an academic freedom case likely headed to court, the attorney for professor John McAdams called the latest response from Marquette University “disingenuous” and cautioned that the case shows, “at Marquette, you apparently speak at your own risk.”… Read more here.
» Read More -
Tenured Professor’s Free Speech Lawsuit Looms Over Marquette as Deadline Approaches
April 14, 2016
By Peter Jesserer Smith at National Catholic Register MILWAUKEE — After the exchange of ultimatums and expiring deadlines, a lawsuit that could be filed as early as today now looms ever-closer for Marquette University amid its ongoing suspension of tenured professor John McAdams… Read more here.
» Read More -
Commentary: the Marquette Professor who Dared to Speak out
April 11, 2016
By Diana Sroka Rickert at Chicago Tribune Universities are supposed to be a place of exploration, open-mindedness and rigorous debate. But at Marquette University in Milwaukee, speaking up can get you banned from campus and fired from your job… Read more here.
» Read More -
Why the Activist Left Can’t Help its Intolerance
March 31, 2016
By John Daniel Davidson at The Federalist In ancient Rome, damnatio memoriae was the practice of condemning Roman elites and emperors after death. The phrase means, “the condemnation of memory,” and the idea was to dishonor people by erasing them from history, usually by seizing their property, removing their name from public monuments, and destroying or re-working their statues. As you might imagine, those subject to damnatio memoriae tended to be traitors or deposed emperors—like Maximian, who ruled Rome for a decade before he was forced to commit suicide by Constantine the Great in 310… Read more here.
» Read More -
Catholic College Moves to Fire Prof Who Defended Marriage
March 30, 2016
By Douglas Ernst at WND Marquette University, which bills itself as a Catholic institution, is moving to fire a professor who defended a student’s right to oppose same-sex marriage. Professor John McAdams found himself under investigation by officials at the Wisconsin college in November 2014 after blogging on philosophy professor Cheryl Abbate. She allegedly said, “You don’t have a right in this class to make homophobic comments,” when a student disagreed with her… Read more here.
» Read More -
George Orwell Call Your Office: Marquette Demands Ritual Apology From Embattled Professor
March 29, 2016
By David French at National Review There’s nothing like a good show trial to build confidence in the academy’s commitment to academic freedom. Marquette University is demanding that embattled professor John McAdams apologize for criticizing a colleague as a condition for keeping his job. And what outrage did McAdams commit? He tried to protect the academic freedom and free speech of conservative students: … Read more here.
» Read More -
Marquette Conservative Prof. Suspended, Required to Admit ‘Guilt’ to Keep Job
March 28, 2016
By Peter Fricke at Campus Reform A well-known conservative professor at Marquette University was officially suspended last week, and is also being required to admit “guilt” for expressing opinions critical of the university on his personal blog. … Read more here.
» Read More -
Ten Schools that Hate Free Speech the Most
March 2, 2016
By Bob Kellogg at One News Now The Foundation for Individual Rights in Education has once again put together its Top 10 list of America’s institutions of learning that support unconstitutional speech codes. Read more here.
» Read More -
McAdams: Marquette Has a Way of Quietly Making Professors Go Away
February 22, 2016
By M.D. Kittie at Wisconsin Watchdog MILWAUKEE, Wis. – John McAdams’ professional fate remains in limbo more than a year after Marquette University initiated the process to fire its outspoken political science professor. Read more here.
» Read More -
FIRE Ranks the 10 Worst Schools for Free Speech
February 18, 2016
By Chris Nuelle at Campus Reform The Foundation for Individual Rights in Education (FIRE), recently released its annual list of universities that are notoriously bad for freedom of speech for 2016. Read more here.
» Read More -
University of Tulsa, OU Make List of Worst Colleges for Free Speech
February 17, 2016
By Staff at News On 6 The University of Tulsa and the University of Oklahoma have made a list of the ten worst colleges for free speech. Read more here.
» Read More -
Marquette University Again Named One of 10 Worst Colleges for Free Speech
February 17, 2016
By Karen Herzog at Journal Sentinel Marquette University for the second year in a row has been named one of the nation’s 10 worst colleges for free speech on a list published by The Huffington Post, but the university begs to differ. Read more here.
» Read More -
Marquette Makes List of 10 Worst Colleges for Free Speech
February 17, 2016
By M.D. Kittle at Wisconsin Watchdog MILWAUKEE – Thanks to its stubborn assault on academic freedom, Marquette University finds itself – again – on the top 10 list of the worst colleges for free speech, according to a new ranking compiled by the Foundation for Individual Rights in Education. Read more here.
» Read More -
FIRE Unveils This Year’s List of Worst Colleges for Free Speech
February 17, 2016
By Leah Barkoukis at TownHall.com As high school juniors across the country begin the college search process, there’s no doubt school ranking, academic programs, and cost are all important factors in the decision-making process. But students (and their parents who likely foot most of the bill) ought to be mindful of one other aspect when considering which college or university is the best fit for them: free speech on campus. Read more here.
» Read More -
LSU on List of 10 Worst Colleges for Free Speech
February 17, 2016
By The Daily Advertiser at Shreveport Times PHILADELPHIA — Nearly half of America’s top colleges maintain speech codes that blatantly violate First Amendment standards, and this year Louisiana State University is one of them, according to a report from the Foundation for Individual Rights in Education (FIRE). Read more here.
» Read More -
Can Opposing Same-Sex Marriage Get You Fired at Marquette University?
November 13, 2015
By M.D. Kittle at The Daily Signal MADISON, Wis.—John McAdams remains in professional limbo at his Jesuit school. The long-time Marquette University political science professor at the center of one of the most controversial academic freedom cases in higher education continues to wait for a faculty hearing committee’s decision on his professional fate. Marquette has said it intends to fire McAdams because of his blog post a little over a year ago criticizing a student teacher for prohibiting a philosophy student from sharing his opposition to same-sex marriage in the class. The faculty committee, which held a hearing into the matter in September, has 90 […]
» Read More -
From Marquette to Mizzou, Free Speech is Under Politically Correct Assault
November 12, 2015
By M.D. Kittle at Wisconsin Watchdog MADISON, Wisc. — John McAdams remains in professional limbo at his Jesuit school. The long-time Marquette University political science professor at the center of one of the most controversial academic freedom cases in higher education continues to wait for a faculty hearing committee’s decision on his professional fate. Marquette has said it intends to fire McAdams because of his blog post a little over a year ago criticizing a student teacher for prohibiting a philosophy student from sharing his opposition to same-sex marriage in the class. The faculty committee, which held a hearing into the matter in […]
» Read More -
Student Newspaper Says ’Emotional Injury’ Justifies the Squelching of Unpopular Speech
October 23, 2015
By Greg Piper at The College Fix The fall term just started and student newspapers across the country are already reeling from actions that threaten their ability to publish controversial and unpopular speech. We’ve covered several here, particularly the kerfuffle that Wesleyan University’s Bryan Stascavage provoked when he wrote a (mildly) critical column about the Black Lives Matter movement. Hundreds of Argus copies were stolen, its staffers (including Iraq war veteran Stascavage) intimidated by activists, and its funding source potentially threatened by the student government. The Foundation for Individual Rights in Education offers this rundown of the year so far: Brown University’s Daily Herald apologized […]
» Read More -
Professor’s Peers are Judging Whether He Should be Fired for Defending a Student Who Opposes Gay Marriage
September 21, 2015
By Greg Piper at The College Fix John McAdams, the Marquette University professor whose tenure is being threatened because he criticized a colleague in a blog post for silencing a student’s views against gay marriage, could be one step closer to getting fired today. A committee of his peers will help decide whether his academic freedom is protected or ignored in the interest of protecting people from offense. Watchdog.org reports that the Faculty Hearing Committee, which serves an advisory role to the administration, is meeting today to decide whether to recommend McAdams’ tenure be stripped. McAdams says the committee is biased against him: […]
» Read More -
Professor To Face His Peers Soon In Marquette University Academic Freedom Fight
September 8, 2015
By M. D. Kittle at Watchdog.org MILWAUKEE — John McAdams’ long legal limbo may soon be coming to an end. The nationally acclaimed Marquette University political science professor at the center of one of the more closely followed academic freedom battles will finally have his day before his peers later this month. Marquette’s Faculty Hearing Committee is scheduled to meet Sept. 21 to weigh whether McAdams should be stripped of his tenure for a blog post he wrote in November that criticized a graduate student teacher who told a student he couldn’t discuss his opposition to gay marriage in her class. The instructor […]
» Read More -
Marquette’s Removal of Mural Featuring Assata Shakur Creates Buzz
May 20, 2015
By Karen Herzog at Milwaukee Wisconsin Journal Sentinel A Gender and Sexuality Resource Center created after Marquette University drew fire for rescinding a job offer to a lesbian candidate for a dean’s position is grabbing national headlines of its own after a mural it displayed was swiftly removed by campus officials, and the center’s director either resigned under pressure or was fired. Marquette officials on Wednesday declined to discuss the nature of the director’s sudden departure, saying only that Susannah Bartlow no longer is employed there and it’s a personnel matter. “We will work with the Center’s advisory board to […]
» Read More -
Harvard Faculty Backs Democrats 96% of the Time, Says School Paper
May 1, 2015
By Maxim Lott at Fox News Republicans running for president might as well skip any fundraisers at Ivy League universities like Harvard, where a new analysis shows 96 percent of faculty donations over the last three years went to Democrats. Academia in general, and the elite northeastern schools in particular, have long been seen as a bastion for left-wing professors. Nationally, about two-thirds of college professors say they are liberal and less than a tenth identify themselves as conservative, according to one study. The imbalance at Harvard, uncovered by the student newspaper Harvard Crimson surprised even Harvard administrators. “If someone gets in trouble […]
» Read More -
Waiting Games Goes on For Professor Caught in Marquette Speech Battle
March 31, 2015
By M.D. Kittle at WisconsinWatchdog.org MADISON, Wis. – There aren’t many academicians who know more about John F. Kennedy’s assassination than John McAdams. The Marquette University political science professor wrote the book on the conspiracy theories surrounding the 35th president’s public murder — and the web page. His work, described as “impressively comprehensive,” has spanned a 40-year academic career, most of which he has spent at Marquette. Now McAdams’ professional fate, in large part, rests in the hands of a jury of his peers presiding over one of the more intriguing speech- and academic-freedom cases to confront a U.S. college campus.This nationally respected […]
» Read More -
Higher Ed., Lower Thinking: 2 States Dumb-Down Student Speech
March 12, 2015
By Bob Kellogg at OneNewsNow A university in Utah believes that students should not say or post anything that “disparages” or mocks any individual — even including Cuban revolutionary Che Guevara — while a university in Wisconsin prohibits all speech that can cause “emotional discomfort.” In the Beehive State, Young Americans for Liberty (YAL) students at Dixie State University filed a lawsuit after the school refused to approve YAL promotional flyers that featured negative images of Barack Obama, George W. Bush and Marxist revolutionary Che Guevara. Foundation for Individual Rights in Education (FIRE) executive director Robert Shibley argues that such […]
» Read More -
Top 10 Worst Offenders of Free Speech on College Campuses
March 6, 2015
By Napp Nazworth at The Christian Post The Foundation for Individual Rights in Education released its list of the top 10 worst offenders of free speech on college campuses in 2014. The top 10, in alphabetical order, are: Brandeis University, California State University-Fullerton, Chicago State University, Georgetown University, Kansas Board of Regents, Marquette University, Modesto Junior College, U.S. Department’s of Education and Justice, University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign, and University of Iowa. FIRE, founded in 1999, advocates for individual rights at American colleges and universities. It was founded by University of Pennsylvania professor Alan Charles Kors and civil liberties attorney […]
» Read More -
Marquette University Placed On FIRE’s List of Worst Free Speech Offenders After Tenure Fight With Conservative Professor
March 3, 2015
By Ashley Dobson at Red Alert Politics Foundation for Individual Rights in Education announced its fourth annual list of the top 10 threats to free speech on campus this week and to no one’s surprise, the major controversy at Marquette University had caught the attention of the organization. Marquette is currently in the process of trying to revoke the tenure of conservative professor John McAdams thanks to his personal blog. The controversy between John McAdams and Marquette stems from a blog post from last November in which he reported on his liberal colleague’s refusal to allow a conservative student to debate the topic […]
» Read More -
Firing Professor McAdams: When a Catholic University Collides With Political Correctness
February 18, 2015
By Howard Kainz at The John William Pope Center In my 35 years of teaching in the Marquette University philosophy department, there were always some faculty (including the present chair) who were quite public about having “partners.” I never witnessed any discrimination against them, nor was I aware of any attempts on their part to impose ideology in classes. I never encountered any difficulty in discussing the pros and cons of “hot button” issues such as homosexuality or abortion in my ethics and philosophical anthropology classes. (My 1999 book, Politically Incorrect Dialogues: Topics Not Discussed in Polite Circles, was an […]
» Read More -
Where Do You Get Punished For Defending Free Speech? At A University, Of Course
February 16, 2015
By Bob Kellogg at OneNewsNow A Wisconsin university is punishing a professor who criticized an instructor for telling her students to support same-sex marriage in her class. Professor John McAdams, a conservative political science professor, posted comments about the philosphy class on his Marquette Warrior blog, naming the instructor and describing the students’ account of the pro-homosexual propoganda he opposed. Marquette is now trying to take away McAdams’ tenure after suspending him last December pending a review. Peter Bonilla of the Foundation for Individual Rights in Education says McAdams’ suspension is a free-speech rights issue. If a faculty member can have his tenure revoked […]
» Read More -
Editorial: Stop Squelching Free Speech At College Campuses
February 13, 2015
By Las Vegas Review-Journal At Las Vegas Review Journal College campuses are supposed to be marketplaces of ideas, where no one should be afraid to study and debate controversial ideas. If a university limits speech, it limits study — to say nothing of stomping our most important rights. Count the University of Michigan among the campuses caving to political correctness. Michigan has launched a $16,000 “inclusive language campaign” designed to teach students which words are considered offensive and should not be used around others. As part of the campaign, posters have been put up around campus warning students not to […]
» Read More -
Marquette Professor Becomes Face of National Campus Free Speech Battle
February 6, 2015
By M.D. Kittle at Watchdog.org MADISON, Wis. — A respected academician for nearly 40 years, Marquette University’s John McAdams has now taken on the position of freedom fighter in the battle between speech and left-wing political correctness on college campuses. The embattled political science professor spoke to Wisconsin Reporter Thursday hours after the university began the process to terminate his tenure. McAdams has been on paid suspension and ordered to stay off campus since November, when the political conservative and frequent critic of Marquette administration criticized in his blog a graduate student teacher who wouldn’t allow a student in her philosophy class […]
» Read More -
Marquette Moves To Fire Tenured Conservative Professor For Blog Post
February 6, 2015
By Kaitlyn Schallhorn at Campus Reform Marquette University has moved to fire a tenured conservative professor after he published a blog post about a graduate student instructor’s remarks to a student about gay marriage. Speaking by phone to Campus Reform, Dr. John McAdams confirmed his latest blog post for the Marquette Warrior saying the school has sent him a “Dear John” letter detailing its intent to revoke his tenure and fire him. “They have a history of persuading professors to go quietly and they may think that oh, they can sit down with my lawyer and I’ll agree to just […]
» Read More -
Marquette University Administration Looks To Fire Conservative Tenured Prof
February 6, 2015
By Rick Moran at American Thinker The controversy over a blog posting by Marquette University professor John McAdams continues, as the administration informed the conservative professor that they would seek to revoke his tenure and fire him. McAdams published a blog on his Marquette Warrior site highlighting an incident in an ethics class where the grad student teaching the class told a student not to express his anti-gay marriage views because it may offend some people. McAdams called the instructor out for stifling free speech and academic freedom, which resulted in some nasty e-mails to the grad student. The administration […]
» Read More -
Marquette Professor Fired For Blogging, Academic Freedom Groups Up In Arms
February 6, 2015
By Matt Lamb at The College Fix McAdams ‘should have known’ his whistleblowing would lead to ‘threatening communications’ It has been a rough three months for Marquette University professor and acerbic blogger John McAdams. Because McAdams criticized a graduate teaching instructor for silencing an undergraduate owing to his traditional views on marriage, the school informed him last week his tenure is being revoked and he’ll be fired. Though academic observers debated whether McAdams should have named and shamed now-former Marquette grad student Cheryl Abbate – which led to his temporary banishment from campus and canceled classes – even McAdams’ critics are […]
» Read More -
Firing A Faculty Blogger
February 5, 2015
By Scott Jaschik at Inside Higher Ed A controversial professor on Wednesday revealed that Marquette University is trying to revoke his tenure and fire him for statements he made about a graduate instructor, with her name, on his blog. The university says his behavior was unprofessional and that he misled the public about what happened in a dispute between the graduate instructor and an undergraduate student. The professor, John McAdams, says he is being punished for his free speech. He also maintains that Marquette shouldn’t be attacking him, given that he is defending an undergraduate’s views against gay marriage that […]
» Read More -
Breaking: Marquette To Fire Whistleblower Who Called Out Gay-Marriage Bullying
February 5, 2015
By Greg Piper at The College Fix Political science professor John McAdams will be out of a job for conduct that doesn’t appear to violate any explicit rules at Marquette University. His mortal sin? Blogging. College Fix readers are well aware of the McAdams’ saga: The conservative professor called out a graduate teaching instructor who told a student he couldn’t openly disagree with gay marriage in class – at a Catholic university, of all places. He got banned from campus, apparently because he named a grad student… who happens to have authority over undergrads. McAdams shared a lengthy letter he got […]
» Read More -
Marquette Trying To Fire Tenured Professor Who Blogged About Grad Student Instructor’s Suppression Of Anti-Gay-Marriage Views
February 5, 2015
By Eugene Volokh at The Washington Post Scott Jaschik (Inside Higher Ed) has a detailed report; the Foundation for Individual Rights in Education and John K. Wilson (the American Association of University Professors’ Academe blog) (writing for himself, not the AAUP) weigh in on Professor John McAdams’ side, and both link to relevant documents. I’m at a conference and traveling, but I thought I’d pass along the links, and an excerpt from the Inside Higher Ed post: A controversial professor on Wednesday revealed that Marquette University is trying to revoke his tenure and fire him for statements he made about […]
» Read More -
Marquette University Trying to Fire Prof for Criticizing Pro-Gay Instructor
February 5, 2015
By Robby Soave at Reason Online Marquette University is moving forward with its plan to fire a tenured professor over his criticisms of an instructor who wouldn’t let any of her students speak out against gay marriage in class. The controversy is interesting for a couple reasons—a Catholic university is essentially punishing a professor whose views on gay marriage are perfectly aligned with church doctrine, for one thing—but most notably, raises important questions about the institution’s commitment to academic freedom. The professor, John McAdams, is known for espousing politically conservative views. He wrote on his blog about a situation involving […]
» Read More -
Fight Erupts Over University’s Censorship Of Student Speech
January 10, 2015
By Michael F. Haverluck at WND The censorship of student speech at Marquette University has drawn the attention of several outside organizations, with one legal team demanding the reinstatement of a professor who blogged about an argument in which a teacher allegedly warned a student that any criticism of same-sex “marriage” and its related issues was banned. The Wisconsin Institute for Law & Liberty, or WILL, has written a letter demanding that the school reinstate professor John McAdams to his tenured position because the university’s suspension over his advocacy for academic freedom violated the school’s own commitment to that cause, […]
» Read More -
College Campuses’ Feelings-Based Tyranny
December 19, 2014
By John Leo at National Review Online At Marquette University, an ethics teacher refused to allow a class discussion on gay marriage because gays in the room might be offended by negative opinions. At Harvard Law, Dean Martha Minow cited “hurt” as her reason for sending a campus-wide e-mail excoriating a student who said, in a private message, that some research on race and intelligence might be worthwhile. At Oberlin, a thousand people signed a petition to “discontinue the standard grading system” this semester for black students because they have ”suffered significant trauma” from the grand jury decisions in the Ferguson and […]
» Read More -
Marquette Harassment Policy Insulates Students From Real World
December 19, 2014
By Christian Schneider at Milwaukee Journal Sentinel Last Sunday afternoon, my phone buzzed with a bit of fan mail. The sender said he hopes my daughters “get touched by a big black guy” who will “turn them out on crack,” and invited my “soul mate” to perform an act so vile just mentioning it would get one thrown out of an adult video convention. (And I’m pretty sure Jennifer Lawrence doesn’t appreciate being referred to in that manner.) Like 95% of the adult population, I shrugged it off and moved on with my life. Most of us are pretty good […]
» Read More -
Marquette U. Grad Student She’s Being Targeted After Ending A Class Discussion On Gay Marriage
November 20, 2014
By Colleen Flaherty at Inside Higher Ed Leading classroom discussions — especially those about controversial ideas — is a juggling act that can challenge even the most seasoned professors. There’s a clock to watch, student interest to gauge, and facts, opinions and personalities to navigate. Success or flop, though, most of the time those discussions end at the classroom door. But that wasn’t the case at Marquette University over the last month. Thanks to a cell phone and the internet, a graduate student instructor of philosophy there has found herself at the center of a firestorm over how she treated […]
» Read More -
Marquette Instructor Who Silenced Student Wants Cyberbullying Policy
November 20, 2014
By Greg Piper at The College Fix Following up on our story about Marquette University instructor Cheryl Abbate and her dispute with a student who complained she wouldn’t let students openly disagree with gay marriage in a philosophy class: Abbate is now going on the offensive. In a thorough summary of the dispute – which oddly leaves out the alleged role of philosophy department chair Nancy Snow in intimidating the student – Inside Higher Edreports that Abbate is calling for the school to crack down on the people who criticized her: Abbate, however, said she hoped Marquette would “use this event […]
» Read More -
Student Told He Can’t Openly Disagree With Gay Marriage In Class At Jesuit College
November 17, 2014
By Matt Lamb at The College Fix Marquette University, a Jesuit institution, is in hot water with both Catholic conservatives and free speech advocates for a philosophy instructor’s alleged discrimination against a student for privately disagreeing with gay marriage. The student, who asked to remain anonymous, told The College Fix that the chair of the department is trying to cover up her own involvement in scolding the student and pressuring him to identify a university employee whom he asked for help in the dispute. The accusations were first aired by Marquette political science professor John McAdams, who knows the student, […]
» Read More -
Banned in Marquette: No free speech zone for the words of Dave Barry
September 29, 2009
I worked for three years on the sixth floor of One Herald Plaza and never bumped into the infamous Dave Barry. He never invited me up to the roof to fire potatoes into Biscayne Bay from his gas-powered spud gun. I worked for the afternoon Miami News and he for the morning Miami Herald. I did sit at home on Sunday mornings and laugh till I cried over his humor column in the Tropic Sunday supplement section of the Miami Herald. I especially enjoyed his surprised discovery of the unique flora and fauna of Dade County when the paper finally […]
» Read More -
Campus Alert: Banning Dave Barry
June 11, 2007
As college students head off to summer vacation, it’s time to look back at the academic year’s most ridiculous case. When it came to being just plain nuts, one university distinguished itself above all others this year: Marquette University in Wisconsin and its crackdown on Dave Barry. That’s right: Even all-American humorist Dave Barry is subject to censorship on our nation’s college campuses, as Ph.D. student Stuart Ditsler found out last fall. Ditsler didn’t think he was doing anything objectionable by posting a Dave Barry quote on his office door last October—but James South, the head of Marquette’s philosophy department, […]
» Read More -
It’s all a free-speech zone
October 22, 2006
Milwaukee Journal Sentinel Editorial We were under the impression that the entire United States is a free-speech zone. Which is why the phrase’s use is puzzling in the case of a teaching aide and graduate student at Marquette University who had a quote from a well-known humorist removed from his office door recently. The quote from Dave Barry was, “As Americans we must always remember that we all have a common enemy, an enemy that is dangerous, powerful, and relentless. I refer, of course, to the federal government.” Philosophy department chairman and associate professor James South called the quote […]
» Read More -
University bans humor quotation from student’s door
October 19, 2006
by Nathan Burchfiel Cybercast News Service Officials at Marquette University have ordered a Ph.D. student to remove a quotation critical of the federal government from his office door, because the hallway the door faces is not a “free speech zone.” In August, Stuart Distler, a doctoral student teacher, posted a quotation from humor columnist Dave Barry on his office door. “As Americans, we must always remember that we all have a common enemy, an enemy that is dangerous, powerful and relentless,” the sign stated. “I refer, of course, to the federal government.” On Sept. 5, Philosophy Department Chairman James South […]
» Read More -
Free speech group ridicules Marquette for removal of Barry quote
October 19, 2006
A national free speech group lambasted Marquette University administrators Wednesday for removing a quote by humorist Dave Barry from a graduate student’s office door. The Foundation for Individual Rights in Education criticized a Marquette administrator for removing this Barry quote from the office door of doctoral student Stuart Ditsler last month: "As Americans we must always remember that we all have a common enemy, an enemy that is dangerous, powerful, and relentless. I refer, of course, to the federal government." Philosophy Department Chair James South said in a Sept. 5 e-mail that he removed the quotation, which was posted in […]
» Read More -
I am not making this up: Dave Barry is “patently offensive”
October 18, 2006
The free-speech fun squad at the Foundation for Individual Rights in Education (FIRE) reports on the latest suppression of expression on campus: In August, a grad student at Marquette University in Milwaukee posted a Dave Barry quote on his office door. The quote reads: “As Americans we must always remember that we all have a common enemy, an enemy that is dangerous, powerful, and relentless. I refer, of course, to the federal government.” On September 5, says FIRE: Philosophy Department Chair James South sent [student Stuart] Ditsler an e-mail stating that he had received several complaints and therefore removed the […]
» Read More -
Prof sails against liberal tide
April 17, 2005
WILMINGTON — The door to the office of Mike Adams, associate professor of criminal justice at UNC-Wilmington, seems more like a window into his soul. The bumper stickers, fliers, advertisements, printouts and photographs attached to the door provide a vivid sociopolitical view of the office’s occupant. Can’t feed ’em, Don’t breed ’em. Every fourth baby dies from Choice. Straight white male — The final minority. So you’re a feminist. Isn’t that cute. The door is so cluttered that its earlier decorations have been all but covered — most notably the sign declaring Adams’ office to be the campus “Men’s Resource […]
» Read More
-
John McAdams returns to Marquette with upbeat attitude, no regrets
September 11, 2018
John McAdams may have won his academic freedom battle against Marquette University this summer, but one might imagine that more than three years of campus banishment, the precarious status of his tenured political science professorship, and a nationally-watched Wisconsin Supreme Court case over whether Marquette could fire him for contentious posts on his personal blog would take some kind of toll. “No, no, no.” McAdams deadpans in his trademark hard-nosed, unsentimental manner. He waves away questions about whether he suffered during his leave, which finally ended last month when Marquette grudgingly reinstated him. And he’s equally dismissive of questions about […]
» Read More -
Wisconsin Supreme Court: Marquette University wrongly fired professor for opinions on personal blog
July 6, 2018
Three and a half years after being fired for critiquing a graduate student’s attempt to silence a student critical of gay marriage, professor John McAdams can return to the classroom MADISON, Wis., July 6, 2018 — In a win for academic freedom, the Wisconsin Supreme Court ruled today that Marquette University wrongly fired Professor John McAdams for comments he made on his personal blog in 2014. The Foundation for Individual Rights in Education filed a “friend of the court” brief last November urging the court to hear McAdams’ case and reach this result. McAdams criticized a graduate teaching instructor by […]
» Read More -
AAUP files brief in support of Marquette professor John McAdams
April 3, 2018
The American Association of University Professors has filed an amicus brief on behalf of Marquette University professor John McAdams in his case before the Wisconsin Supreme Court. The brief bolsters McAdams’s case as he seeks to vindicate his due process and academic freedom rights. This legal saga started in November 2014 when McAdams criticized a graduate student instructor on his blog for directing a student to refrain from opposing same-sex marriage in her classroom. After the story became national news, Marquette suspended McAdams and required him to recant the blog and apologize in order to be reinstated. This prompted McAdams […]
» Read More -
UPDATE: Wisconsin Supreme Court agrees to hear appeal from fired Marquette University professor
January 29, 2018
Last week, the Wisconsin Supreme Court agreed to hear an appeal by Professor John McAdams in his lawsuit against Marquette University. McAdams was fired by Marquette for criticizing a graduate instructor on his personal blog. McAdams’ lawyers petitioned Wisconsin’s highest court to hear the case, bypassing the intermediate appellate court. FIRE filed an amicus curiae brief in support of the petition. Following the dismissal of McAdams’ case by the Milwaukee County Circuit Court, FIRE hopes that the Wisconsin Supreme Court’s willingness to hear the case indicates its appreciation of the case’s importance to free expression and academic freedom on Wisconsin’s […]
» Read More -
FIRE files amicus brief with Wisconsin Supreme Court in McAdams v. Marquette
November 29, 2017
FIRE has filed an amicus brief with the Wisconsin Supreme Court in the case of John McAdams, the tenured Marquette University professor who was fired after criticizing a graduate student instructor’s pedagogical techniques on his personal blog. FIRE filed the brief this afternoon, along with a request that the court consider it as it decides whether to hear McAdams’ case. McAdams said in May that he would appeal the decision of a Milwaukee circuit court judge who ruled that, despite Marquette’s contractual promises of free speech and academic freedom, Marquette was within its rights when it effectively fired McAdams back […]
» Read More -
Marquette professor John McAdams vows appeal after setback in suit against university
May 5, 2017
For more than two years now, FIRE has covered the case of Marquette University professor John McAdams, who was suspended by Marquette in December 2014 for criticizing a graduate student instructor on his personal blog. McAdams sued the university over his treatment last year. Yesterday, McAdams’ claims were dismissed by the Milwaukee County Circuit Court, which granted Marquette’s request for summary judgment, finding that McAdams was not unduly punished. In its press release yesterday, the Wisconsin Institute for Law & Liberty, which represents McAdams in his lawsuit against Marquette, summarized McAdams’ case as follows: In November, 2014, McAdams shared […]
» Read More -
John McAdams Sues Marquette University for Suspension Over Blog Post
May 2, 2016
The tenured Marquette University political science professor suspended in 2014 for blogging about a student’s dispute with an instructor over a class discussion of gay marriage announced today he will sue the university. Marquette suspended John McAdams in December 2014 after McAdams took to his personal blog, Marquette Warrior, to criticize a graduate student instructor who told a student that expressing opposition to same-sex marriage was inappropriate in her class. In January 2015, Marquette announced its intention to revoke McAdams’ tenure and terminate him from the Marquette faculty. At a press conference this morning, McAdams and the Wisconsin Institute for […]
» Read More -
Marquette Continues to Earn ‘Worst School’ for Free Speech Label With New Punishments for McAdams
March 25, 2016
A suspension through the fall 2016 semester and a compelled apology: that is the punishment reportedly imposed on Marquette University Professor John McAdams yesterday. The punishment stems from his 2014 online criticism of a graduate student instructor who told a student not to oppose same-sex marriage in her class at the Catholic university. This development comes as the result of recommendations made to Marquette President Michael Lovell by a faculty hearing committee in January. However, according to a report today from Inside Higher Ed, a lawyer for McAdams claims that the faculty panel never recommended, in its confidential 123-page report, […]
» Read More -
FIRE Announces 10 Worst Colleges for Free Speech: 2016
February 17, 2016
PHILADELPHIA, February 17, 2016—Nearly half of America’s top colleges maintain speech codes that blatantly violate First Amendment standards. But every year the Foundation for Individual Rights in Education (FIRE) takes a closer look at the past year’s incidents of college censorship to determine the nation’s 10 worst abusers of student and faculty free speech rights. This year’s list of the 10 worst colleges for free speech—published with detailed descriptions at The Huffington Post—includes many public colleges or universities bound by the First Amendment. Some of them, on the other hand, are private colleges that, though not required by the Constitution […]
» Read More -
Marquette Faculty Hearing Committee to Weigh in on McAdams Tenure Dispute
September 18, 2015
Next week, suspended Marquette University political science professor John McAdams will face the next step in his tenure revocation battle with the Jesuit university. Marquette’s Faculty Hearing Committee is scheduled to meet on September 21 to consider whether McAdams should be stripped of his tenure following his December 2014 suspension for commentary on his personal blog. The controversy culminating in McAdams’ suspension from teaching began in November 2014, after the professor posted an entry to his blog, the Marquette Warrior, criticizing a then-graduate student instructor, Cheryl Abbate, for preventing a discussion of negative views towards gay marriage in her class […]
» Read More -
After Public Criticism, Marquette Removes Mural and Announces Faculty Departure
May 22, 2015
Earlier this week, Marquette University painted over a mural in its Gender and Sexuality Resource Center (GSRC) depicting Assata Shakur (also known as Joanne Chesimard), a woman who escaped from prison and fled to Cuba after her conviction for murdering a New Jersey state trooper in 1973, earning her a spot on the FBI’s most wanted list. Now the university has stated that the director of the GSRC, Susannah Bartlow, is “no longer an employee with Marquette University,” leading media to presume she was fired because of the controversial mural. Although the mural had been on display in the GSRC […]
» Read More -
Speech Code of the Month: Marquette University
March 9, 2015
FIRE announces its Speech Code of the Month for March 2015: Marquette University. If you’ve been following higher ed news or reading The Torch recently, you are probably aware that Marquette University is no friend of free speech. In fact, FIRE recently named Marquette one of the ten worst abusers of free speech for its “chilling campaign to revoke the tenure of political science professor John McAdams due to writings on his private blog.” It may not surprise you to learn, therefore, that Marquette also maintains highly restrictive speech codes. While Marquette’s policies impermissibly restrict a variety of student speech, […]
» Read More -
Marquette’s Consistent Inconsistency on Academic Freedom, Tenure, and Civility
March 4, 2015
Over recent weeks, my colleague Peter Bonilla has treated Torch readers to a series of articles on the case of Marquette University professor John McAdams, who faces losing tenure for criticizing graduate instructor Cheryl Abbate’s direction to a student not to voice his opposition to same-sex marriage in class because it might offend his classmates. Peter’s three-part series explored Marquette’s disregard for due process and its subversion of basic free speech principles, and it thoroughly refuted Marquette’s absurd argument that the case is not about academic freedom and free speech. But we’re not through with Marquette just yet. Today, I […]
» Read More -
Yes, Marquette’s Plan to Fire John McAdams Is About Free Speech and Academic Freedom
March 3, 2015
In two previous Torch entries on Professor John McAdams’s fight to keep his tenure at Marquette University, I’ve focused on Marquette’s abuses of McAdams’s due process rights and the subversions of basic free speech principles it has used first to justify his suspension, and then to justify its aim of revoking his tenure. In this third and final entry McAdams’s case, my focus is on perhaps the most outrageous and dangerous argument Marquette has made to defend its position. In a statement released February 4, Marquette president Michael R. Lovell argued that the university’s designs against McAdams’s tenure “have everything […]
» Read More -
FIRE Announces 10 Worst Colleges for Free Speech in 2014
March 2, 2015
PHILADELPHIA, March 2, 2015—More than half of America’s top colleges maintain speech codes that blatantly violate First Amendment standards. But every year the Foundation for Individual Rights in Education (FIRE) takes a closer look at the previous year’s incidents of college censorship to determine the nation’s 10 worst abusers of student and faculty free speech rights. This year’s list of the 10 worst colleges for free speech—published with detailed descriptions at The Huffington Post—includes many public colleges or universities bound by the First Amendment. Some of them, on the other hand, are private colleges that, though not required by the […]
» Read More -
Marquette’s Dangerous Subversion of Free Speech
February 16, 2015
Last week, I wrote about the systemic due process failures at Marquette University, which plans to fire tenured political science professor John McAdams for criticism of a graduate student and philosophy instructor published on his blog. As I wrote, “No one concerned for fundamental fairness in campus proceedings should be okay with the extent to which Marquette has flouted its obligations in McAdams’s case.” In this second of my three-part series of Torch entries examining the myriad faults with Marquette’s case against McAdams, I focus on Marquette’s dangerous subversion of basic free speech principles to suit its purposes. Marquette is […]
» Read More -
The Travesty of Due Process at Marquette
February 10, 2015
As we announced last week, Marquette University is moving to revoke the tenure of professor John McAdams and fire him from the Marquette faculty because of opinions and criticisms voiced on his blog, Marquette Warrior. The controversial decision was triggered by McAdams’s criticism of a graduate instructor, who he felt wrongly suppressed the expression of certain opinions in her “Theory of Ethics” philosophy course. After the blog post gained widespread media attention, Marquette unilaterally suspended McAdams, and on January 30 it informed him that it intended to revoke his tenure in response to his writing. In this first of a three-part […]
» Read More -
After Gay Marriage Flap, Marquette Moves to Fire Tenured Prof
February 5, 2015
MILWAUKEE, Wisc., February 5, 2015—Disregarding freedom of speech, academic freedom, and its own policies, Marquette University will attempt to revoke Professor John McAdams’s tenure and fire him. Marquette is taking action against McAdams, a political conservative and frequent critic of the administration, supposedly in response to his online criticism of a graduate student instructor who told a student not to oppose same-sex marriage in her class. Marquette had previously suspended McAdams without due process, treated him as though he presented a violent threat, and cancelled his current semester’s classes. The Foundation for Individual Rights in Education (FIRE) has called for […]
» Read More -
Marquette Professor’s Lawyer Smacks Down Dean’s Weak Justification for Suspension
January 22, 2015
Over a month after he was suspended from teaching and banned from campus, Marquette University professor John McAdams has yet to be presented with clear disciplinary charges against him. Marquette’s Dean of Klingler College of Arts and Sciences Richard Holz did, however, offer his explanation as to why the university was “review[ing McAdams’s] conduct and considering all appropriate responses” in a letter dated January 2. Yesterday, McAdams’s lawyer and president of the Wisconsin Institute for Law & Liberty (WILL) Rick Esenberg wrote a letter thoroughly explaining why the university’s statements thus far have been self-contradictory and insufficient to justify McAdams’s […]
» Read More -
Marquette Fails to Follow Procedures in Suspending Professor
December 30, 2014
Earlier this month, Marquette University professor John McAdams was suspended from his teaching duties, apparently for a November 9 blog post criticizing a class instructor. The Wisconsin Institute for Law & Liberty (WILL), representing McAdams, wrote a letter to the university (PDF) on December 22 arguing that the suspension violates Marquette’s explicit promises to its professors and must be rescinded. As FIRE reported in November, McAdams’s blog post alleged that a graduate student teaching an ethics class told her students that the issue of gay rights was settled and that it would not be discussed in class. The instructor was, […]
» Read More -
Eyes on Marquette University as Faculty Blogger Suspended
December 18, 2014
In recent weeks, FIRE has written about a controversy at Marquette University brought to light by political science professor John McAdams, in which an instructor informed a student that expressing opposition to same-sex marriage was not appropriate for a classroom setting. We expressed our concerns in a pair of Torch entries. This week, FIRE and others have learned that McAdams has been suspended from teaching and banned from the Marquette campus while he is under investigation. The Milwaukee Journal Sentinel is among the outlets that have reported this development, and law professor Eugene Volokh has offered his preliminary impressions of […]
» Read More -
On Marquette Classroom Controversy, Rebuttal Ignores Facts
November 18, 2014
On his philosophy news site Daily Nous, University of South Carolina associate professor Justin Weinberg responded today to a blog post I wrote about hostility towards certain viewpoints at Marquette University. In his post, Weinberg argued that graduate student Cheryl Abbate was the “target of a political attack” by one of her students and that she was simply abiding by Marquette’s harassment policy, not censoring student speech, when she told him certain viewpoints weren’t welcome. Weinberg’s reasoning is flawed on several levels. To review: A student in Abbate’s ethics class objected to her allegedly stating that “everybody agrees” on the […]
» Read More -
Marquette U. Prohibits Disagreeing with Classmates—If You Oppose Same-Sex Marriage
November 11, 2014
Marquette University, a Roman Catholic institution in Wisconsin, is swiftly establishing itself as a place where not all viewpoints are welcome—even if those viewpoints align with those of the Catholic Church. On his (non-university-affiliated) Marquette Warrior blog, Marquette political science professor John McAdams wrote this weekend about an incident that occurred in Cheryl Abbate’s “Theory of Ethics” class. McAdams reported: [Abbate] listed some issues on the board, and came to “gay rights.” She then airily said that “everybody agrees on this, and there is no need to discuss it.” [A] student, a conservative who disagrees with some of the gay […]
» Read More -
Marquette Harassment Training Forbids Certain Viewpoints
October 1, 2014
FIRE hopes readers are hungry for more news about problematic Title IX training courses, because professors and graduate assistants at Marquette University in Wisconsin are evidently required to complete a course that grossly misstates what kind of expression is acceptable in the university workplace. Campus Reform and Marquette Warrior, a blog run by Marquette political science professor John McAdams, both have posted screen captures and information on the course, which is designed to inform staff, including faculty members, about sexual harassment and sexual violence. McAdams notes on his blog that the course starts off by stating that unlawful harassment must […]
» Read More -
Marquette University Threatens Academic Freedom with Chilling Investigation of Classroom Speech
December 29, 2011
Over at the blog Marquette Warrior, John McAdams provides a good example of how unwarranted investigations of campus speech can cause a deeply problematic “chilling effect” at a university. Universities must not pursue investigations of protected expression just because someone submits a complaint; as soon as it is clear that the expression in question is protected speech, the inquiry must end, even if there are other factual disputes. Prolonging the investigation tells everyone on campus that the university will pursue charges against you no matter how frivolous or malicious the complaint. The likely result is that people self-censor and keep […]
» Read More -
This Month in FIRE History: Muzzling Dave Barry at Marquette
October 17, 2011
Fresh on the heels of our case at the University of Wisconsin–Stout, it seems appropriate to look back five years at a similar case involving an overzealous administration and an “offensive” poster. In October 2006, Marquette Ph.D. student Stuart Ditsler came to FIRE for help after Philosophy Department Chair James South removed a flyer quoting well-known humor writer Dave Barry from his office door. The quote read, “As Americans we must always remember that we all have a common enemy, an enemy that is dangerous, powerful, and relentless. I refer, of course, to the federal government.” Despite the fact that […]
» Read More -
This Month in FIRE History: Dave Barry Speaks Out on College Censorship
July 30, 2010
Exactly one year ago, FIRE released a video of Pulitzer Prize-winning humorist Dave Barry in which he discusses the value of free speech on college campuses. The video, which now has over 24,000 hits, shows Barry’s perspective on FIRE’s work and why it’s so important. In 2006, Barry’s writing was the subject of a FIRE case when a Ph.D. student at Marquette University posted a quote from one of Barry’s columns on his office door that the administration deemed “patently offensive”—a legal term of art usually used in the context of evaluating hardcore pornography. The quote read, “As Americans we […]
» Read More -
Marquette’s Strained Relationship with Freedom of Expression
May 11, 2010
Marquette University made headlines recently for offering the job of Dean of Arts and Sciences to sexuality and gender scholar Jodi O’Brien. Marquette is a major Catholic university, and although O’Brien is open about being a lesbian, there is no evidence that this was an obstacle for either the search committee or Marquette administrators. Marquette, after all, has an anti-discrimination policy that includes sexual orientation as a protected status. But that’s not why the appointment made headlines. The reason the story is in the news is that, shortly after offering O’Brien the deanship, Marquette rescinded the offer. Marquette President Father […]
» Read More -
Dave Barry, Award-Winning Humorist, Speaks Out on College Censorship in New FIRE Video
July 30, 2009
Dave Barry, Pulitzer Prize-winning humor columnist and author of more than 30 books, is no stranger to critics trying to censor his writing. The nationally syndicated humorist has written some of our nation’s funniest columns—and with the First Amendment on his side, he’s been winning the battle for free speech for over 25 years. Today, we are releasing a new video that features Barry discussing why freedom of expression is important to him and how today’s politically correct college campuses are creating a culture of censorship that stifles humor writing and the opinions of millions of students across the country. […]
» Read More -
Dave Barry, Award-Winning Humorist, Speaks Out on College Censorship in New FIRE Video
July 30, 2009
PHILADELPHIA, July 30, 2009—Dave Barry, Pulitzer Prize-winning humor columnist and author of more than 30 books, is no stranger to critics trying to censor his writing. The nationally syndicated humorist has written some of our nation’s funniest columns—and with the First Amendment on his side, he’s been winning the battle for free speech for over 25 years. Today, the Foundation for Individual Rights in Education (FIRE) releases a new video that features Barry discussing why freedom of expression is important to him and how today’s politically correct college campuses are creating a culture of censorship that stifles humor writing and […]
» Read More -
Radical Speech: Dave Barry Talks About Politically Correct Campuses
July 30, 2009
Dave Barry, Pulitzer Prize-winning humor columnist and author of more than 30 books, is no stranger to critics trying to censor his writing. The nationally syndicated humorist has written some of our nation’s funniest columns—and with the First Amendment on his side, he’s been winning the battle for free speech for over 25 years. This new video from FIRE features Barry discussing why freedom of expression is important to him and how today’s politically correct college campuses are creating a culture of censorship that stifles humor writing and the opinions of millions of students across the country.
» Read More -
Today’s ‘Campus Alert’: Banning Dave Barry
June 11, 2007
Our Campus Alert column in today’s New York Post focuses on the FIRE case we have crowned our most ridiculous case of the past academic year—Marquette University’s banning of a Dave Barry quote. Last October, Ph.D. student Stuart Ditsler posted a Barry quote on his office door that read, “As Americans we must always remember that we all have a common enemy, an enemy that is dangerous, powerful and relentless. I refer, of course, to the federal government.” Within days, Philosophy Department Chair James South deemed the quote “patently offensive” and ordered its removal, all the while maintaining in […]
» Read More -
Looking for a Straight Answer from Marquette University
January 15, 2007
Marquette University’s censorship of a Dave Barry quote was one of the more confounding cases of 2006. Marquette’s reaction to the quote—a benign criticism of the government—went from baffling to exasperating when administrators tried to justify the censorship, first by claiming that the quote was “patently offensive,” then that office doors are not “free speech zones,” then that it was only in “the context of a complaint” that Marquette is willing to forsake its community members’ free speech rights. In the hope that Marquette will push past these excuses to clarify whether students and faculty are allowed to express themselves […]
» Read More -
Still No Answer from Marquette
December 27, 2006
As the year draws to a close and we reflect on all of FIRE’s activities in 2006, the case of Stuart Ditsler at Marquette University stands out not only for its absurdity but also because the case has yet to be resolved. Torch readers will recall Ditsler’s case from earlier this fall, when administrators removed a Dave Barry quote from his office door in Marquette’s philosophy department because they deemed it “patently offensive.” The quote—which could not be considered “patently offensive” (a term usually reserved for hardcore pornography) by any stretch of the imagination—read: “As Americans we must always remember […]
» Read More -
American Federation of Teachers (AFT) Questions Marquette
December 5, 2006
The AFT features FIRE in its new AFT On Campus column “Academic Freedom Forum.” Discussing the Stuart Ditsler case, the column reads: We think of faculty doors as a place for posting office hours, inspiring quotes, and other provocative or silly items at the occupant’s discretion. But at Marquette University, one philosophy grad student has found Dave Barry is beyond the pale. After briefly discussing the details of the case, the column asks, “A free speech violation, or just an indignity of the academic pecking order?” Perhaps it is both, but as FIRE points out in its latest letter to […]
» Read More -
FIRE Continues to Follow Dave Barry Incident at Marquette
November 15, 2006
FIRE continues to follow the case of Stuart Ditsler, the graduate student at Marquette University who was forced to remove an innocuous political quote by humorist Dave Barry from his office door. Although the Marquette administration claimed that the situation was resolved within the philosophy department, Ditsler told FIRE he was never notified of this alleged resolution. So the question remains: are students and faculty now permitted to post materials on their office doors at Marquette? FIRE wrote to Marquette a second time, hoping to clarify the university’s position and establish a firm commitment to free speech on campus. […]
» Read More -
Student Editorial Highlights FIRE Case at Marquette University
November 8, 2006
A recent editorial in The Daily Barometer, the student newspaper at Oregon State University, picked up on the absurdity of FIRE’s recent case at Marquette University where the chair of the philosophy department, Dr. James South, removed a quote from humorist Dave Barry from a graduate student’s office door because South found the quote “patently offensive.” The quote read: As Americans, we must always remember that we all have a common enemy, an enemy that is dangerous, powerful, and relentless. I refer, of course, to the federal government. If the quote doesn’t seem adequately nocuous to create any sort of […]
» Read More -
Marquette’s Student Newspaper on Censorship at Marquette
October 30, 2006
The Marquette Warrior blog brought to my attention an editorial by the Marquette Tribune, Marquette’s student newspaper, on the university’s failure to respond to FIRE’s letter about the philosophy department’s censorship of a Dave Barry quote. Usually, student newspapers are fairly reliable friends of liberty on campus. However, this does not appear to be the case with the Marquette Tribune, which criticizes Marquette President Robert Wild for not answering FIRE’s letter on time, but adds: The university could have easily defended South’s actions with its Student Handbook policy. Despite the romantic impressions of some, Marquette is a private institution—not a […]
» Read More -
A Belated Response from Marquette
October 24, 2006
FIRE just received Marquette University’s response to our September 27 letter. Marquette said publicly that it sent us the letter on October 16, and the letter is indeed dated October 16, but the postmark is dated October 19, the day after FIRE’s press release on Marquette’s censorship of a Dave Barry quote. Curious indeed. Even more curious is the explanation that Marquette President Robert Wild gives for censoring the quote. He writes, “the original difficulty arose out of a misunderstanding… [W]hen the quotation cited was posted, it was without attribution; therefore, someone reading the quotation may not have understood the […]
» Read More -
No Marquette Letter Yet
October 20, 2006
Although it has appeared on several blogs, FIRE has still not received the response from Marquette University it claims to have sent on October 16. Perhaps the letter got lost it the mail, or perhaps Marquette backdated the letter in order to appear responsive to FIRE’s concerns. In any event, FIRE hopes that it will soon be able to see this mysterious letter.
» Read More -
Jesuit university faces fresh heat
October 20, 2006
The Foundation for Individual Rights in Education is petitioning Marquette University to reconsider allowing a graduate student to post a quote by humorist Dave Barry on the student’s office door. The quote, which was removed two months ago by MU Philosophy Department Chair James South, is “pretty tame,” according to FIRE President Greg Lukianoff. “Marquette has very strong and clear promises of free speech,” Lukianoff said. “But they wouldn’t even tolerate a quote by light-hearted humorist Dave Barry.” The quote that appeared on the door, according to FIRE, read: “As Americans, we must always remember that we all have a […]
» Read More -
‘Milwaukee Journal Sentinel’ Covers Marquette/Dave Barry Controversy
October 19, 2006
The Milwaukee Journal Sentinel covered FIRE’s recent case at Marquette University where an administrator removed an innocuous quote by comedian Dave Barry from the office door of graduate student Stuart Ditsler, claiming the quote was “patently offensive.” The quote read: “As Americans we must always remember that we all have a common enemy, an enemy that is dangerous, powerful, and relentless. I refer, of course, to the federal government.” In a bizarre twist, the article claims that Marquette President Robert Wild sent a letter to FIRE dated October 16, claiming that the offending quote was removed from the door […]
» Read More -
Marquette Controversy Rapidly Gaining Attention
October 19, 2006
FIRE’s involvement at Marquette University has been picked up by the Associated Press, Special Report with Brit Hume on Fox News, and the Milwaukee Journal Sentinel. Add to this blogs on several websites—from organizations including the John Locke Foundation and the Cato Institute to Dave Barry himself—and numerous responses from individuals who have written to Marquette’s administration in support of Stuart Ditsler. Considering the amount of feedback FIRE has received on this case, we hope the university will soon see the error of its ways and decide that office doors (which have traditionally been places where professors and students post […]
» Read More -
TV Critic Glenn Garvin Calls Evil by its Name: Dave Barry
October 18, 2006
Miami Herald television critic Glenn Garvin has caught wind of FIRE’s recent case at Marquette University, where an administrator removed a quote from comedian (read: Evil Incarnate) Dave Barry that a graduate student had posted on his office door. Garvin came down squarely against the raw tyranny of freedom of expression and against the “practically unfathomable evil of Dave Barry.” On the Changing Channels blog of the Miami Herald, Garvin lauds the bravery of the “heroic Anti-Dave Freedom Fighters of Marquette University,” especially “Thought Police Chief James South,” chair of the Marquette philosophy department, whose quick thinking saved Marquette University […]
» Read More -
The Good, the Bad, and the Just Plain Silly
October 18, 2006
As a free speech organization, we see pretty much every type of censorship out there. People are frequently censored at colleges and universities for engaging in controversial political speech. Other times, people are censored for engaging in speech that is crude and repugnant, but that is wholly protected. And then there are times that people seem to be censored for no reason at all. Today’s case at Marquette University is one of those instances. In the spirit of levity, here are a few more of the silliest instances of censorship we’ve seen here at FIRE: Gonzaga University tried to punish […]
» Read More -
Dave Barry Quote Sparks Dispute at Marquette University
October 18, 2006
Today’s press release highlights a free speech dispute at Marquette University in Milwaukee. Philosophy Ph.D. student Stuart Ditsler posted a quote by writer and humorist Dave Barry on his office door. The quote read, “As Americans we must always remember that we all have a common enemy, an enemy that is dangerous, powerful, and relentless. I refer, of course, to the federal government.” Seems harmless enough. But within days, Ditsler received an e-mail from Philosophy Department Chair James South, who had removed the quote after receiving complaints. South wrote, “I’m afraid that hallways and office doors are not ‘free-speech […]
» Read More -
Marquette Bans Dave Barry Quote from Office Door
October 18, 2006
MILWAUKEE, Wis., October 18, 2006—Writer and humorist Dave Barry probably never expected that one of his jokes would spark a university free speech dispute. But in early September, a Marquette University administrator removed a Barry quote about the federal government from Ph.D. student Stuart Ditsler’s office door because the quote was “patently offensive.” Facing this arbitrary exercise of political censorship, Ditsler contacted the Foundation for Individual Rights in Education (FIRE) for help. “There have been several high-profile free speech controversies on campuses recently, such as at Columbia this month. But incidents like this one at Marquette and on other campuses […]
» Read More -
Free speech group ridicules Marquette for removal of Barry quote
October 18, 2006
A national free speech group is criticizing Marquette University administrators today for removing a quote by humorist Dave Barry from the office door of a graduate student. The Barry quote on Stuart Ditsler’s door read: “As Americans we must always remember that we all have a common enemy, an enemy that is dangerous, powerful, and relentless. I refer, of course, to the federal government.” Philosophy Department Chair James South says he took the quotation down after receiving several complaints. An e-mail released by Philadelphia’s Foundation for Individual Rights in Education says South explained that the hallways and office doors at […]
» Read More -
Free-speech group decries Marquette removal of quote
October 18, 2006
Marquette University came under attack from a national free-speech organization on Wednesday after a university administrator refused to allow a quote from humorist Dave Barry to remain posted on the office door of four teaching assistants. The quote: “As Americans we must always remember that we all have a common enemy, an enemy that is dangerous, powerful, and relentless. I refer, of course, to the federal government.” Stuart Ditsler, a teaching assistant and graduate student in the philosophy department, said he put it on the door of an office he shares with several other graduate students several weeks before classes […]
» Read More -
FIRE Letter to Marquette University President Robert A. Wild, September 27, 2006
September 27, 2006
September 27, 2006 President Robert A. Wild, S.J. Marquette University O’Hara Hall, 101/102 P.O. Box 1881 Milwaukee, Wisconsin 53201-1881 Sent via U.S. Mail and Facsimile (414-288-3161) Dear President Wild: As you can see from our directors and board of advisors, FIRE unites civil rights and civil liberties leaders, scholars, journalists, and public intellectuals across the political and ideological spectrum on behalf of liberty, due process, legal equality, voluntary association, and, in this case, freedom of speech and academic freedom on America’s college campuses. Our website, www.thefire.org, will give you a greater sense of our identity and of our activities. FIRE […]
» Read More